Three men convicted of murdering Perth brothers Callum and Jake Robinson and their American friend Jack Carter Rhoad on a Mexican surf trip will be sentenced this Friday.
On 9 October all three men were found guilty of aggravated homicide, violent robbery and vehicle theft with violence. The verdict was delivered by Judge Raúl Hernández in Ensenada, Baja California at the end of a trial that ran for about a month.
Baja California’s Chief Prosecutor, María Elena Andrade Ramírez, said her office would seek 210-year jail terms for each man, and described the killings as ‘cowardly’. The court found the men had acted with premeditation, although Baja California law limits sentences to a maximum of 60 years.
Debra and Martin Robinson traveled from Perth for the trial and were in court for the verdict alongside an Australian consular official. The day before the judgment, Mrs Robinson urged the court to impose the maximum sentences. Mr Robinson called the verdict a significant moment in the family’s long and painful pursuit of justice for their sons and their friend.
The verdict brings accountability, but it can never bring the brothers home.
For Callum, 33, and Jake, 30, the ocean was a thread running through lives that had taken them far from Perth. The brothers grew up surfing and swimming and carried their love for the ocean into adulthood.
In April 2024, Jake flew to California to visit his brother before starting a new hospital job in Geelong. The pair went to Coachella, then headed south from San Diego with Mr Rhoad, 30, for surfing and camping in Baja California.
Near Punta San José, south of Ensenada, that promise ended in devastating violence. The men were reported missing on 27 April 2024 after failing to arrive at booked accommodation. On 3 May, their bodies were found at the bottom of a well near Punta San José, with their burnt-out pickup truck nearby. All three had been shot.
Early accounts suggested a car theft that turned deadly when the men resisted. Evidence heard in court painted a more harrowing picture. Ary Gisell Silva Raya, the former girlfriend of García Cota, testified that he told her the men handed over their keys and wallets and begged for their lives.
Silva Raya was jailed for 20 years earlier this year after pleading guilty to robbery with violence. Prosecutors said she approached the three foreigners at Punta San José and encouraged her companions to rob them.
Back home, hundreds gathered off Sorrento for a memorial paddle-out in June 2024. The family’s foundation now carries the brothers’ generosity forward, supporting others and protecting the beaches they loved.
For the surfing community, their story reaches beyond a courtroom: two brothers, a friend, and lives full of possibility. Their mother’s appeal remains a fitting tribute: “Please live bigger, shine brighter and love harder in their memory.”




